What AI Cites When It Recommends a St. Louis Business

We asked ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, and Claude 36 questions about St. Louis businesses in 12 industries, then sorted every page they cited.

Get your AI visibility report

Key Findings

A citation is a source an AI answer links to or displays. Each answer can cite several sources. The percentages use different totals. “Share of citations” counts cited pages within the stated question type, industry, or platform. “Share of answers” counts answers that included a source, once per answer. “Sites in common” compares distinct websites. None of these measures counts customer visits or recommendations.

  1. On narrow questions, 60% of citations went to a business’s own website. On “best in St. Louis” questions, it was 25%.
  2. The gap held 5 days later. Asked again on 3 platforms, narrow questions sent 55% of citations to business websites, against 17% for “best in St. Louis.”
  3. Google AI Mode drew 61% of its citations from Google Business Profiles. Perplexity and Claude cited directories only through local list pages.
  4. For the 29 questions with usable Google results, 16% of AI citations to external websites came from a site on Google’s first page. Just 4% matched the exact page Google showed.
  5. For the same question, sites cited by both platforms made up about 8% of the distinct sites cited by either platform, on average across platform pairs and questions.
  6. Google Business Profiles appeared in more answers than any other source, all of them from Google AI Mode. Yelp came next, cited only by Claude and AI Mode.
  7. ChatGPT answered all 36 questions, covering city, county, and specific needs. Business websites received 29% of its city citations and 55% of its narrow-question citations.

These are patterns in the answers we captured, not proof that changing a page will get a business cited. AI answers change by platform, by day, and by who is asking.

Narrow Questions Sent AI to Business Websites

In our captured answers, broad questions such as “best plumbers in St. Louis” drew more citations to directories and review sites. Questions about specific needs, such as sewer line replacement, drew more citations to businesses’ own websites. Every specific-need question named St. Louis; none substituted a suburb or another county.

Narrow Questions Sent AI to Business Websites

Share of citations that went to a business’s own website, by type of question

  1. “Best [industry] in St. Louis”25%245 citations
  2. “Best [industry] in St. Charles County”31%241 citations
  3. A specific need60%238 citations

144 answers across 12 industries. Each cited page counts once per answer.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

The Pages AI Cited for Narrow Questions

On narrow questions, 86 of 143 citations to business websites went to pages other than the homepage. Examples included service pages that directly matched the customer’s need.

The questionThe page AI cited
“Best plumber in St. Louis for a sewer line replacement”Hoffmann Brothers, sewer line replacement page
“Best custom home builder in St. Louis to build on my own lot”Hibbs Homes, build on your lot page
“Best mortgage lender in St. Louis for first-time home buyers”Central National Bank, first-time home buyer page
“Who should I call for emergency furnace repair in St. Louis”Air Comfort Service, emergency heating page
“Best contractor for a kitchen remodel in St. Louis”McDermott Remodeling, kitchens page

What It Means for Your Business

Start with the specific services customers ask you about. Check whether your website explains those services, who they are for, and where you provide them. The cited service pages above are useful examples to compare with your own.

See Where Your Business Shows Up in AI Answers

We check broad and specific customer questions across the major AI platforms, including the business websites, directory lists, and profiles they cite.

Get your AI visibility report

On narrow questions, AI cited a business’s own page 2.3 times as often as a directory.

On each of the 4 platforms, narrow questions sent a bigger share of citations to business websites than “best in St. Louis” questions did. The same was true in 11 of the 12 industries. Remodeling contractors were the exception: the business-website share fell on the kitchen remodel question, where directories such as Houzz and HomeAdvisor still took most citations.

A narrow question differs from a broad one in more than scope. It names a job, like a sewer line replacement, and directories may have no page for that job at all. So this shows where AI looked for each kind of question, not that adding a page will get a business cited.

Business Websites Gained Visibility on the Narrow Question in 11 of 12 Industries

Share of citations that went to a business’s own website, by industryShare of citations to business websites

  1. Dentists10% 73%
  2. HVAC companies35% 95%
  3. Accountants33% 86%
  4. Home builders39% 82%
  5. Roofers25% 67%
  6. Real estate agents0% 40%
  7. Landscapers45% 76%
  8. Mortgage lenders20% 50%
  9. Plumbers32% 60%
  10. Personal injury lawyers14% 40%
  11. SEO agencies8% 17%
  12. Remodeling contractors35% 23%

Each industry had 12 to 24 citations per question type. Read the pattern across rows.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

The Sources AI Cited Most for St. Louis Businesses

Across the 12 industries, AI cited 286 different sites, and 182 of them appeared in only one answer. A short list of directories showed up again and again. Even the most frequent source appeared in just 17% of all 144 captured answers, so no single source dominated the whole study.

A local list page includes several businesses, such as a list of St. Louis plumbers. A profile page describes 1 business. Google Business Profile cards are the business listings AI Mode displays with links to their Google profiles; we count those cards as directory profiles.

This ranking counts answers, not citations. A source counts once in an answer even if several of its pages are cited. Because an answer can cite several sources, these percentages do not need to add up to 100%.

Google Business Profiles Appeared in More Answers Than Any Other Source

Share of the 144 answers that cited each source, for every source cited in at least 6 answersShare of all 144 answers

  1. 1Google Business ProfilesGoogle profiles17%12
  2. 2yelp.com15%10
  3. 3expertise.com10%8
  4. 4houzz.com10%3
  5. 5bbb.org8%7
  6. 6hibbshomesusa.com6%1
  7. 6homeadvisor.com6%3
  8. 6mo.gov6%7
  9. 9bestprosintown.com5%5
  10. 9semrush.com5%1
  11. 11angi.com4%4
  12. 11hoffmannbros.com4%2
  13. 11insiteadvice.com4%1
  14. 11thumbtack.com4%3

182 of 286 sites appeared once. Google Business Profiles count as one source. Colors show each site’s most-cited page type.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

Google Business Profiles and Yelp Led the Source Rankings

Google Business Profiles led, appearing in 17% of all 144 captured answers and covering all 12 industries. Every one of those appearances came from Google AI Mode. Yelp came next, appearing in 15% of the same 144 answers, though only Claude and AI Mode cited it. hibbshomesusa.com and hoffmannbros.com also appeared among the most-cited sources.

Each Industry Leaned on Different Sources

The leading sources varied by industry. In 7 of 12 industries, 1 source appeared in more answers than any other. But 4 of those leaders were ahead by only 1 answer. The remaining industries, mortgage lenders, landscapers, dentists, personal injury lawyers, and accountants, had a tie for first place. Treat these rankings as a shortlist of places to check, rather than a reason to focus on a single winner. Industry-specific directories often appeared near the top: Houzz for remodelers and landscapers, Justia for injury lawyers, U.S. News for real estate agents, and Semrush’s agency directory for SEO agencies.

Business Websites Led the Source Mix in 4 Industries, Directories in 8

Share of citations by source type, by industry, sorted by business websitesShare of citations by industry

Other: news, government, associations, and forums.

  1. HVAC companies62%22%12%
  2. Home builders60%25%10%
  3. Landscapers56%39%
  4. Accountants50%31%12%
  5. Plumbers41%42%10%
  6. Roofers36%50%8%
  7. Mortgage lenders34%41%11%14%
  8. Dentists32%49%13%
  9. Remodeling contractors28%61%9%
  10. Personal injury lawyers19%63%10%8%
  11. SEO agencies17%54%27%
  12. Real estate agents16%84%
See the numbers
Percentages use each row’s citation total.
Business websitesDirectories and review sitesBest-of listsNews, government, and forumsCitations
HVAC companies62%22%12%4%69
Home builders60%25%5%10%60
Landscapers56%39%5%0%66
Accountants50%31%7%12%59
Plumbers41%42%10%7%61
Roofers36%50%8%6%66
Mortgage lenders34%41%11%14%56
Dentists32%49%13%6%53
Remodeling contractors28%61%2%9%64
Personal injury lawyers19%63%10%8%63
SEO agencies17%54%27%2%64
Real estate agents16%84%0%0%43

Tap or click a source type to compare.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

SEO agencies were the outlier. Only 17% of citations on SEO-agency questions went to an agency’s own website. Another 27% went to best-of lists of St. Louis SEO companies, some of them published by other marketing agencies ranking the field, such as Fuel Online. Formbreak’s own sites weren’t among them.

See each industry’s top 3 sources
Industry1st2nd3rd
Real estate agentsrealestate.usnews.com 4 answerseffectiveagents.com 3 answersGoogle Business Profiles 3 answers
Home buildershibbshomesusa.com 8 answersmcbridehomes.com 4 answersreahomesllc.com 4 answers
Mortgage lendersfirstcommunity.com 4 answersmidwestbankcentre.com 4 answersbankwithstifel.com 3 answers
Remodeling contractorshouzz.com 8 answershomeadvisor.com 4 answerslistondesignbuild.com 3 answers
Roofersbbb.org 4 answerscardinalcontractors.com 3 answersconnerroofing.com 3 answers
HVAC companiesscottleeheating.com 5 answersaircomfortservice.com 3 answersdesignaire.net 3 answers
Plumbershoffmannbros.com 5 answersyelp.com 4 answershomeadvisor.com 3 answers
Landscapershouzz.com 5 answerstimberlinelandscapes.com 5 answersbigbendlandscaping.com 3 answers
DentistsGoogle Business Profiles 3 answersreviews.birdeye.com 3 answerswebmd.com 3 answers
Personal injury lawyersbestlawyers.com 5 answersjustia.com 5 answersattorneys.superlawyers.com 3 answers
Accountantsdunncpafirm.com 3 answersexpertise.com 3 answersfarmer.cpa 3 answers
SEO agenciessemrush.com 7 answersinsiteadvice.com 6 answersclutch.co 4 answers

Counts are answers citing the source. Each industry had 12 to 12 answers across its 3 questions. Equal counts are ties, listed alphabetically. With this few answers, one more or one fewer can change the order.

Which Directory Pages Got Cited Depended on the Platform

Directories and review sites took 46% of all citations, but the platforms cited very different kinds of directory page. Across all 36 questions, covering city, county, and specific needs, every directory citation from Perplexity and Claude went to a local list page, such as Expertise.com’s page of St. Louis plumbers. This describes their directory citations, not all the sources they cited. Google AI Mode leaned on Google Business Profiles, 82 of its 134 citations. ChatGPT cited one business’s profile, such as a BBB page, in 53% of its directory citations.

Every Directory Citation From Perplexity and Claude Was a List Page

Share of directory citations that were local list pages, across all 36 questions on each platformDirectory citations that were list pages

  1. All 4 platforms61%332 citations
  2. ChatGPT44%72 citations
  3. Google AI Mode13%104 citations
  4. Perplexity100%84 citations
  5. Claude100%72 citations

The rest were profiles or other directory pages.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

Counting directory list pages and best-of lists together, list pages made up 37% of all citations. County questions leaned hardest on directories, at 60% of citations, against 51% on St. Louis questions and 26% on specific needs.

St. Charles County Questions Leaned Hardest on Directories

Share of citations that went to directories and review sites, by type of questionDirectory share by question type

  1. “Best [industry] in St. Louis”51%245 citations
  2. “Best [industry] in St. Charles County”60%241 citations
  3. A specific need26%238 citations

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

List Pages AI Cited

The pageIndustryCited in
Houzz, home remodelers near St. CharlesRemodeling contractors3 answers
U.S. News, real estate agents in St. LouisReal estate agents3 answers
FindLaw, injury lawyers in St. Charles CountyPersonal injury lawyers2 answers
WebMD, dentists in St. LouisDentists2 answers
Expertise.com, plumbers in St. LouisPlumbers1 answer

4 AI Platforms, 4 Different Source Lists

Each platform built its answers from its own mix of sources.

Each Platform Leaned on a Different Mix of Sources

Share of citations by source type, by AI platformShare of citations by platform

Other: news, government, associations, and forums.

  1. ChatGPT44%34%17%
  2. Google AI Mode17%78%
  3. Perplexity48%38%11%
  4. Claude36%45%18%
See the numbers
Percentages use each row’s citation total.
Business websitesDirectories and review sitesBest-of listsNews, government, and forumsCitations
ChatGPT44%34%5%17%212
Google AI Mode17%78%3%2%134
Perplexity48%38%11%3%220
Claude36%45%18%1%158

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

Google AI Mode leaned hardest on directories, at 78% of its citations, most of them Google Business Profiles. Directories accounted for 45% of Claude’s citations. Government and association pages made up 15% of ChatGPT’s citations, including state and county license lookups. Business websites made up 48% of Perplexity’s citations, the largest business-website share of any platform.

No 2 Platforms Shared More Than 15% of Their Sources on Average

Average share of cited sites 2 platforms had in common when they answered the same questionSources 2 platforms had in common

ChatGPTAI ModePerplexityClaudeChatGPT2%12%9%AI Mode2%4%6%Perplexity12%4%15%Claude9%6%15%

The grid is mirrored, so each pair appears twice. A pair at 10% shared about 1 in 10 of the sites either one cited.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

Even on the same question, the platforms usually cited different sites. For each question and pair of platforms, we counted all distinct sites either platform cited. Sites cited by both made up only 8% of that combined set, on average. They weren’t strangers, though: in 33 of the 36 questions, at least 2 platforms cited the same site.

Most AI Citations Came From Outside Google’s First Page

We saved Google’s first page of regular results for every question, 7 to 9 web results each. For 7 questions, Google’s results came back for the wrong search or nearly empty, so this section uses the other 29. Only 16% of AI citations to external websites came from a site on that first page, and 4% from the exact page Google showed.

Few AI Citations Came From Google’s First Page

Share of citations from a site on Google’s first page for the same questionCitations from Google’s first-page sites

  1. All 4 platforms16%
  2. ChatGPT10%
  3. Google AI Mode23%
  4. Perplexity20%
  5. Claude17%

Based on the 515 citations to outside sites on the 29 questions with usable Google results. Google Business Profiles are left out of this comparison.

Formbreak · St. Louis AI Citation Study · 2026

Looking in the other direction, about 22% of Google’s first-page sites were cited by at least 1 AI platform for the same question. For this percentage, each site counts once per question across the 29 usable Google searches. Some pages appeared in both: Air Comfort Service’s emergency heating page, one of the pages above, was also Google’s top result for its question. Among each platform’s citations to external websites on those 29 questions, 10% of ChatGPT’s citations and 23% of Google AI Mode’s citations came from Google first-page sites, the lowest and highest shares respectively.

A 5-Step AI Visibility Checklist for Your Business

Use this checklist to review your website and the outside sources that describe your business. These are practical recommendations from Formbreak, informed by the study; we did not test whether making these changes increases citations.

  1. Check Your Pages Against Specific Customer Questions

    On narrow questions, 60% of citations went to business websites, and 86 of those 143 citations went to pages other than the homepage. Give each distinct core service a dedicated page that explains the work, who needs it, and where you offer it. Use the homepage to introduce those services and link to the details. Closely related variations can share a page when they answer the same customer need.

  2. Check Your Google Business Profile

    Google AI Mode displayed Google Business Profile cards in all 12 industries. Those cards made up 61% of its citations. Check that your profile accurately describes your services and service area.

  3. Review the Local Lists AI Cites

    Perplexity and Claude cited directories through local list pages. Find the pages cited for your town and your trade. If your business is missing, check how the publisher selects businesses and whether you can submit or update your information.

  4. Check Your Industry’s Most-Cited Sources

    Houzz, Justia, and U.S. News were near the top for remodelers, injury lawyers, and real estate agents. Review your industry’s short list for missing or inaccurate information. Differences between the leading sources were often just 1 answer.

  5. Check Each Platform Directly

    On the same question, sites shared by 2 platforms made up about 8% of the distinct sites either cited, on average. Ask the same customer questions on each platform, and record whether your business is named and whether your website is cited. Keep those checks separate from Google rankings and website visits.

What We Saw on ChatGPT

We captured all 36 ChatGPT answers: 12 city questions, 12 county questions, and 12 narrow questions. Business websites received 29% of city citations and 55% of narrow-question citations. Business websites received 49% of citations in ChatGPT’s county answers.

It also stood out in 2 ways. ChatGPT cited government and association pages for 15% of its citations, more than any other platform, including state and county license lookups. And when it cited a directory, it usually cited one business’s profile in 53% of its directory citations, rather than a list. It never cited Yelp, Justia, or U.S. News. If your trade requires a license, check that your public license record is accurate. Review the cited directory profiles and your own pages too; these are places to check, not proven ways to earn a recommendation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do I Get ChatGPT to Recommend My Business?

Start by making your services clear on your website and checking the outside sources ChatGPT cites for your customer questions. We recommend a dedicated page for each distinct core service, with useful detail about the work, who it is for, and where you provide it. Do not make the homepage or a single general services page carry all the detail for several different services. Closely related variations can share a page when they serve the same need. This takes work, but gives customers a clearer explanation and each service a page you can link to. Also check the directory lists and business profiles cited in the answers. Our ChatGPT capture cited business websites, license lookups, and directory profiles, but it did not test whether changing them earns a recommendation. Track whether ChatGPT names your business as well as whether it cites your website.

Does Ranking on Google Get My Business Into AI Answers?

A Google ranking does not establish whether your business appears in AI answers. For the 29 questions with usable Google results, 16% of AI citations to external websites came from a site on Google’s first page. Track AI mentions and citations separately from your rankings.

Which Directories Matter Most for AI Answers in St. Louis?

The most-cited directories differed by platform and industry. Google AI Mode leaned on Google Business Profiles, only Claude and AI Mode cited Yelp, and Houzz, Justia, and U.S. News were near the top for remodelers, injury lawyers, and real estate agents.

Do I Need a Page for Every County I Serve?

This study does not establish that you need a page for every county you serve. On St. Charles County questions, 13 of the 29 citations to business pages other than homepages went to St. Charles location pages. Consider a county page when you have useful information specific to serving that area. Also review the local directory lists AI cited.

How Often Do AI Answers Change?

The cited sources changed substantially between our 2 captures, 5 days apart. For each platform and question, we counted the distinct sites cited on either date and checked how many appeared on both. That shared portion averaged about 40%. Claude was running a newer model in the retest. The overall pattern held, so repeat your checks before treating one answer as a lasting result. For the API captures, we sent standalone requests without personal chat history or saved memories. The collection tool did not report platform-side personalization settings. In everyday use, memory and conversation context can influence an answer, so 2 people asking the same question may see different recommendations and sources.

Methodology

Formbreak publishes this study and sells SEO and AI search services to St. Louis businesses. Nobody paid to be included, and being cited is not a measure of a business’s quality. Jacob Peistrup, who runs Formbreak, owns livingstlouismo.com. It was cited in 3 answers. The main finding holds without it, though the real estate narrow question drops from 40% to 31% of citations going to business websites. Formbreak’s own sites were not cited in any answer, including the SEO agency questions.

What We Asked

  • 12 industries: real estate agents, home builders, mortgage lenders, remodeling contractors, roofers, HVAC companies, plumbers, landscapers, dentists, personal injury lawyers, accountants, and SEO agencies.
  • 3 questions per industry, 36 in all: “best [industry] in St. Louis,” “best [industry] in St. Charles County,” and one specific need, such as “best plumber in St. Louis for a sewer line replacement.” We wrote all 36 before collecting any answers. The 12 control questions came later, to test a concern raised in review.
  • 4 AI platforms: ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, and Claude, collected through Rankability’s Search Intelligence API except for 1 live capture. The API reported the models as gpt-5.6-terra for ChatGPT, Sonar for Perplexity, and Claude Sonnet 4.5 for Claude on October 29 (Claude Sonnet 5.5 on November 3). It reported no model for Google AI Mode or the live ChatGPT capture.
  • Live capture: after repeated API timeouts, we used the first successful live ChatGPT capture through Rankability Tracker for the St. Charles County mortgage-lender question.
  • Google results: we also saved Google’s first page of regular results for each question, 7 to 9 web results. Of those captures, 7 came back for the wrong search, such as results for Best Buy or Louis Vuitton, or nearly empty, so the Google comparison uses the other 29.
  • Settings: location set to St. Louis, Missouri; English; desktop; one answer per platform per question. The API passed the location to each platform but didn’t report how each one used it.
  • Dates: the main answers were captured on October 29, 2026. 1 ChatGPT answer was recovered on October 30. Another 10 were recovered on November 3 after earlier API failures. Another 4 were recovered on November 4. The retest and control questions were captured on November 3.
  • Coverage: All 4 platforms answered all 36 questions, giving 144 answers in total. Gemini returned a payment error through the API on every attempt and is left out.

What a Captured Answer Looks Like

We asked Claude: “who should I call for emergency furnace repair in St. Louis”

Based on my search results, here are several reputable companies that offer emergency furnace repair services in St. Louis:

24/7 Emergency Services:

Air Comfort Service

This excerpt names Air Comfort Service as 1 of several businesses in the answer. The returned source list included its emergency heating page. We counted that page as 1 citation to a business website. This is an example of what we counted, not an endorsement of the company.

Download this saved answer and its source list (JSON).

How We Sorted the Citations

  • Counting: every page an answer cited counts once for that answer, even if the answer linked it several times. Pages that differ only in their search settings, such as 2 Yelp searches in one answer, also count once. That gave 724 citations from 286 sites.
  • 6 source types: a business’s own website; a directory or review site, such as Yelp, Houzz, or the BBB; a best-of list on a site that isn’t a directory, including one business’s blog post ranking its competitors; news; government or associations; and forums.
  • Google Business Profiles: Google AI Mode showed business cards that open a business’s Google profile, 82 of them in 24 of its 36 answers. We count each card as a directory profile, since it’s the source AI Mode used. Excluding those cards from the citation totals, business websites received 30% of city-question citations and 64% of narrow-question citations.
  • Page detail: directory pages were split into local list pages, single-business profiles, and Google Business Profiles, and business pages into homepages and inner pages.
  • Pooling: shares combine all 4 platforms. Perplexity and Claude supplied 52% of the citations, so the main finding is also checked on each platform alone.
  • Checking: The reader review corrected ClearlyRated’s accounting list to a directory, Insite Advice’s homepage to a business website, and an American Academy of Implant Dentistry page to an association source. A script sorted every citation by its web address, with a few hand rules. We then ran 2 separate review passes that re-ran every number from the raw answers and hand-checked 90 citations, and we corrected the types they flagged, such as Forbes Home’s local pages, which are directory listings, and a sponsored St. Louis Magazine list. A press release on a news site counts as news.
  • Conversation context: for the API captures, we sent standalone requests without personal chat history or saved memories. The API did not report platform-side personalization settings. These captures do not represent every personalized conversation a customer could have.

How We Checked the Findings

  • Retest: we asked all 36 questions again on November 3 on Google AI Mode, Perplexity, and Claude. Narrow questions sent 55% of citations to business websites, against 17% for “best in St. Louis” (62% and 24% on the same 3 platforms on October 29). Business websites rose in 11 of 12 industries, even though sites appearing on both dates made up only about 40% of the distinct sites appearing on either date, averaged across matched platform/question pairs (40% on AI Mode, 44% on Perplexity, and 36% on Claude). Claude had moved to a newer model by then, so its change mixes the model and the day. Individual industries moved more than the totals.
  • Wording control: the narrow questions are singular (“best plumber…”), so on November 3 we also asked a plain singular question per industry, such as “best plumber in St. Louis.” Business websites got 19% of those citations, against 17% for the plural question and 55% for narrow questions that day, so the singular wording doesn’t explain the gap. The word “best” also appeared in 11 of the 12 narrow questions.
  • Chance: resampling the 12 industries 10,000 times, keeping each industry’s 2 questions together, put the gap between 22 and 46 points in 95% of draws. Swapping the 2 question types at random inside each industry produced a gap this large in about 0.1% of tries. Business websites rose in 11 of 12 industries, a split this lopsided about 1% of the time by chance. We wrote the narrow questions ourselves rather than drawing them at random, so these tests speak to these questions.
  • Weighting: averaging each answer’s business-website citation share gave 23% for city questions and 57% for narrow questions. Pooling the captured platforms for each question, then averaging the questions’ business-website citation shares, gave 25% and 59%, respectively.
  • Leaving things out: these percentages are the share of remaining citations going to business websites. With any one platform removed, “best in St. Louis” ranged from 19% to 31% and narrow questions from 54% to 64%. With any one industry removed, the gap stayed between 32 and 39 points. Removing each industry’s most-cited business gave 21% for city questions and 56% for narrow questions.
  • ChatGPT alone: on its 36 answers, the gap between narrow and “best in St. Louis” questions could be anywhere from 4 points to 49 points in 95% of resamples, and business websites rose in 9 of the 12 industries where ChatGPT answered both questions.
  • Spread: the 143 narrow-question citations to business websites went to 94 different businesses.
  • Sorting rules: treating booking pages as directories, or businesses’ own best-of posts as business websites, moved the shares by 3 points or less.

Limits

AI answers change between runs, accounts, and locations, so treat the numbers as a snapshot. The findings show patterns, not causes. Each industry had one narrow question, and a narrow question differs from a broad one in topic and intent as well as scope, so the comparison can’t separate those. Each industry also has a small sample. Every county question was about St. Charles County, so other counties may differ. Source types come from each page’s address and format, not a full review of its content. The study shows which pages AI cited, not whether a business was a good fit for the customer. If we re-run the study, each new capture will be added to the changelog below.

Download the Data

Changelog

Updates to the data or method are listed here. Wording and design changes are not.

DateChange
November 4, 2026Added 4 recovered ChatGPT answers, for the accountant, personal injury lawyer, home builder, and mortgage lender county questions. ChatGPT coverage is now 36 of 36 questions. Classified the newly cited RatingsNearMe, MortgageLenderRankings, and MortgageGrades pages as directory listings. Recalculated the figures and downloads from the saved answers.
October 29 to November 3, 2026Baseline capture of 36 questions across 12 St. Louis industries on 4 AI platforms, with a retest and 12 control questions on November 3. Includes 11 recovered ChatGPT answers from October 30 and November 3 and corrections to ClearlyRated, Insite Advice, and American Academy of Implant Dentistry source classifications. Source-ranking colors now use each site’s most-cited page type.

See Where Your Business Shows Up in AI Answers

We check broad and specific customer questions across the major AI platforms, including the business websites, directory lists, and profiles they cite.

Get your AI visibility report